Synthetic shake roofing is made from durable materials such as rubber, plastic, or polymer blends designed to mimic the look of natural wood shakes. It’s engineered to be lightweight, resistant to cracking, fading, and insect damage, and often comes with long warranties, making it a popular choice for those seeking low maintenance and longevity. Wood shake, on the other hand, is crafted from natural timber and offers an authentic aesthetic, with unique textures and color variations that soften over time. However, wood shakes can be prone to issues like mold, rot, insect infestation, and require regular treatment or maintenance to stay in good condition. Inspecting your roof for signs of wear or damage—such as splitting, warping, or discoloration—can help you gauge the right choice for your home’s climate and your willingness to maintain it regularly.
A good DIY check is to compare the feel and weight of small samples, if available, to see what suits your handling preferences and budget. Also, verify the roof’s structural support because synthetic shakes are typically lighter, which might reduce the need for reinforcements compared to wood. When it comes to hiring a contractor, always ask if they are experienced with both synthetic and wood shake installations in your region, and how the warranty process works for each material. Questions like “Can you provide references for projects with synthetic shakes, and what is the typical lifespan you’ve observed?” or “How do you treat wood shakes to resist moisture and pests, and what is the recommended maintenance schedule?” will help you gain clarity on what suits your home best. While DIY inspection is possible, installation and complex repairs should always be left to professionals to ensure warranty compliance and safety.